I talk about burger historical past and classification a bunch. One subject that comes up slightly usually is whether or not or not a Patty Soften is assessed as a burger. I’ve all the time felt {that a} Patty Soften was a burger. I additionally assume that it’s nearly not possible to mess one up.
What’s the distinction between a Patty Soften and a Cheeseburger?
The OFFICIAL components for a Patty Soften are comparatively easy: Burger patty, rye bread, Swiss cheese & grilled onions. Patty melts should not simply restricted to those components, although.
Under are two variations of Patty Melts, one being the standard model and a non-traditional tackle the well-known sandwich.
I can’t say I ever bear in mind consuming a foul one wherever, and I’ve had them in lots of cities and states. Nonetheless, I do encounter variations within the cheeses (American cheese, cheddar cheese), the protein (floor turkey), the bread (Sourdough), and even some cheese-encrusted bread.
One other factor is that almost all purists say that the rye bread is just griddled on the flat high, not toasted. The Patty Soften ought to style just like the youngster of an incredible burger & grilled cheese sandwich.
Hey, I’m all about that thought!
Historical past of the Patty Soften
Who invented the Patty Soften?


In contrast to the burger or cheeseburger, the place you’ve received many of us claiming to be the creators, the Patty Soften is a product of California. Tiny Naylor owned a sequence of Biff’s Drive-Ins and Tiny Naylor Espresso Store eating places from the late Thirties by means of 1957.
It was there that the Patty Soften made its debut.
Naylor put the meat patties between slices of rye bread as a Patty Soften. Though, the credit score for this concoction belongs on to Tiny Naylor’s eating places in California in the course of the Fifties.
The Tiny Naylor handed away in 1959, however his son Biff (the inspiration for the restaurant identify) now owns the Du-Par’s chain (with a reasonably imply Patty Soften on the menu). His granddaughter Jennifer was a former Govt Chef for Wolfgang Puck.
Whereas I haven’t come throughout the recipe for Tiny Naylor’s authentic Patty Soften, I did discover one for Grampa Tiny’s Patty Soften, which Jennifer served at Wolfgang Puck’s. However, bear in mind, beggars can’t be choosers.
Cool Patty Soften Related Reality
The Beastie Boys‘ 1994 album Sick Communication’s cowl was from Bruce Davison’s 1964 image of Tiny Naylor’s for Esquire journal.




Jennifer Naylor’s Patty Soften Recipe


Patty Soften Elements
- Two tablespoons of butter softened
- 4 slices of rye bread
- Salt and freshly floor pepper to style
- 1 1/2 pound contemporary floor spherical (divided and formed into two oval burgers)
- One tablespoon of olive oil
- One small purple onion, peeled and sliced into rings
- 2 to three slices of Swiss cheese
Patty Soften Directions
- Soften butter over flat high griddle/sizable cast-iron skillet to toast rye bread slices.
- Season burgers with salt & pepper, then grill on a flat high.
- Cook dinner the burgers to medium-rare or desired doneness.
- Put olive oil on the griddle and grill onions till caramelized.
- Soften Swiss cheese slices over every burger.
- Assemble the Patty Melts by inserting cheeseburgers over one slice of every rye toast, high with caramelized onions, after which the remaining slices of rye toast.
The BEST Patty Melts in South Florida
Once I say patty soften, I consider the standard sort. We’re speaking a few beef burger patty with caramelized or grilled onions and Swiss cheese on rye bread.
As soon as assembled, the sandwich is griddled, often with some butter. However at the moment, something between two slices of bread passes for a patty soften.
For this Finest Patty Soften in South Florida record, we will likely be loosey-goosey about what makes the lower. Meaning totally different cheeses, sorts of bread, toasting strategies, and even sauces are concerned.
So slightly than maintain you up, go forth and discover your subsequent favourite patty soften. I’ll be ready to listen to your ideas.
Chug’s Diner


No matter you do, don’t miss out on Chug’s Diner Frita Patty Soften as a result of this fella is a recreation changer. We’re speaking a frita patty of rye bread with Swiss cheese, caramelized onions, papitas, and 1000 Island sauce.
Chug’s Diner
3444 Important Hwy Suite 21
Miami, FL
(786) 353-2940
Coral Bagels


Coral Bagels is a great spot for breakfast, however if you happen to’re paying consideration, you’ll discover a patty soften on the menu. You’d be making an enormous mistake if you happen to didn’t order one with some shoestring fries.
Coral Bagels
2750 SW twenty sixth Avenue
Miami, FL
(305) 854-0336
The Meals Truck Retailer


I like their Wisconsin, and it could be my private favourite if their Texas patty soften wasn’t so rattling good! It’s Meals Truck Retailer‘s tribute to Whataburger with two of their 4.2oz patties, white American cheese, chopped onion, and creamy pepper sauce on two items of Texas toast.
The Meals Truck Retailer
13448 Biscayne Boulevard
North Miami, FL
(305) 952-3941
Grampa’s Cafe and Deli


I needed to eat the patty soften from Grampa’s, which is not any shock as this is likely one of the sandwiches I obsess over. One chew in, and I knew it needed to be on the record.
Grampa’s Cafe and Deli
17 SW 1st Avenue
Dania Seashore, FL
(954) 923-2163
Hate Mondays Tavern


When most people consider Hate Mondays Tavern, BBQ is on their minds. However sadly, you’ll miss out on a real-deal patty soften on rye bread and an award-winning burger on the menu if you happen to persist with the ‘que.
Hate Mondays Tavern
12461 Southwest one hundred and thirtieth Avenue
Miami, FL
(305) 378-4900
Mayor’s Cafe that includes Chef Frankie


This non-traditional patty soften may brighten up any breakfast. The one downside? Chef Frankie of Cafe 72 fame cooks this magnificence up on Friday and Saturday nights. This child is a should!
Mayor’s Cafe
15478 NW 77th Ct
Miami Lakes, FL
(786) 907-4173
Moonlite Diner


Once I assume diner, I believe patty melts. The Moonlite Diner in Hollywood is not any totally different. They received a foul mama jama (marbled rye bread) on their palms, and you want to wash it down with some pecan pie; belief me.
Moonlite Diner
3500 Oakwood Boulevard
Hollywood, FL
(954) 924-2012
Peter Pan Diner


I couldn’t resist stopping on the Peter Pan Diner. However seeing a patty soften on the menu was much more thrilling than a restaurant named after that fella. Was it a shock? Not likely, nevertheless it’s freakin’ scrumptious.
Peter Pan Diner
1216 E Oakland Park Boulevard
Oakland Park, FL
(954) 565-7177